Why? What For? How Come?

The question why? seeks to provide reasons of the two fundamental categories in which we explain things: causality and function.

These two categories can be traced back to the origin of life itself and to understand Daniel Dennett’s cryptic statement, “Natural Selection is thus an automatic reason-finder,” you first must understand how Dennett views reasons.

Reasons provide answers to the questions of why? However, the question why? is subdivided into two categories of what for? and how come? (38). When someone asks “why are your eyes blues?” they are really asking “what causes you to have blue eyes?” or rather, “how come you have blue eyes?” How come? questions seeks the process that explains the occurrence / observation, i.e. a kind of continuity. Understanding how come? questions is the first step in reasoning’s evolution and do not attempt to explain purpose or function (38).

Answers to what for? questions attempt to explain purpose and function (40). What for? seeks to understand function, and then provides meaning of that function in the larger narrative of the occurrence / observation. When someone asks “why are you writing this article?” they are really asking “what is the function / purpose of writing this article?” or rather, “what are you writing the article for?” What for? questions evolve out of how come? questions (40). Once causes are understood from how come? questions, further what for? questions are asked to understand purpose and relevance; the combination of both sets of reasons yield design and purpose.

Dennett’s objective is to explain evolution through Natural Selection by means of reverse engineering—not only reverse engineering our physical observations but also the way we think (design stance), and the way we ask questions and provide answers (intentional stance). Natural Selection starts with how come? reasons and moves to what for? reasons. By showing “how our human world filled with reasons grew out of a simpler world without reasons,” (38) Dennett is paralleling a world filled without purpose (bacteria) growing into a world filled with purpose (multiplying / reproducing organisms).

“The biosphere is utterly saturated with design, with purpose, with reasons (36)… Evolution through Natural Selection is not itself a designed thing, an agent with purposes, but it acts as if it were—occupying the role vacated by the Intelligent Designer” (37). Thus, Natural Selection is an automatic reason-finder (49); over time building reasons from the bottom up, rather than the top down.

Works Cited:

Dennett, Daniel. From Bacteria to Bach and Back: The Evolution of Minds. WW Norton & Company. 2017.

Pick Up Your Copy

  • Prime
  • Kindle
  • Paperback
  • Hardcover
  • Buy
SW Hammond
Your signed copies of Stevie Pearl are in the mail. A big thank you to the nearly 3,000 people who entered the giveaway over on Goodreads!...
SW Hammond
Enter to win a signed copy before the release! With the help of Goodreads , I'm giving away 20 signed copies of Stevie Pearl ahead of the...
SW Hammond
Reserve your copy now! As we move toward the release of Stevie Pearl, more milestones come and go. Officially getting the novel on Amazon is...
SW Hammond
There has never been a better time — there has never been more opportunity than right now — for people to do the right thing. If we do the...
SW Hammond
Should you ever find yourself in a position of influence, you’ll be required to pay the toll of compliance. I am part of the first...
SW Hammond
No matter your political stance, newspapers are organizations of sensationalism, partisanship, editorial opinion, and payola. Journalists...
SW Hammond
Sarah Saturday's dreamy-reflective bedroom pop rock project captivates and compels with earnest songwriting. Sarah Saturday might be my...
SW Hammond
Maybe you can never go home again. But if you could, Ghost Notes would be the soundtrack. For some reason I’ve avoided writing about Ghost...
SW Hammond
Guilty Pleasure? Embarrassed??? Hardly. As much as I love music, and devoted a significant amount of my life to it, I can still be pretty...
SW Hammond
I recently contributed to the following question: what are some of the best books for beginners of philosophy? This is kind of loaded...
SW Hammond
The answers I’ve arrived at could have never been told to me—as I cannot tell them to you—they were achieved through realization by...
SW Hammond
On every measurable scale, no matter which side you are sympathetic toward, The Shortest War In History adds to the long list of Unjust wars...
SW Hammond
I was finally able to extract a bunch of data from an old hard drive. I was sure it contained old writings, school projects and music but...
SW Hammond
As I’ve become older, out of my twenties for a couple of years, I’ve found myself settling into a pattern of reveling in solitude. When I...
SW Hammond
I used to pour my guts out. Seems the only way I ever understood my feelings were to read them. The collection within these pages used to...


Enter your email below and never miss news and new releases from SW Hammond.